
As promised. Here I am. Back with more about the first Happier Hour. I don’t know where to begin. I feel overwhelmed. Immersed. Buzzed. Jazzed. Humbled.
Yes, in my humble (or elitist) opinion, this wine/women/words thing seems to be a recipe for lasting smiles.
Wine. One measly hour before the party started, I realized something. I was dressed (distressed skinny jeans, nautical navy and white T, navy boyfriend blazer with gold buttons, outrageous yellow kicks, Flirt polish on nails and toes. Because you care. Right.) Anyway, something grave occurred to me: I had not bought a single bottle of wine. Not one. And this was meant to be a cocktail and conversation soiree, a gathering for wine and words. The fact that I had not ordered the booze made me smile because it was prime and hilarious evidence of my absentmindedness and general ineptitude, but also because it underscored for me that this was really about conversations/words/ideas. And it was. (Don’t worry. Two cases of wine arrived and were promptly consumed!)
Women. More than sixty women arrived for the first Happier Hour. Husband, the only man (other than the two hunky caterers) braved the sea of estrogen. To be honest, I have imagined Happier Hours growing to include men. I am a product of a coed education; I like the idea of male voices in the mix. But over the course of the evening, several women approached me and told me how wonderful it was to be among just women, that it seemed to make everyone feel less self-conscious. A friend noted that by making it for women, there were no couples which facilitated mingling insofar as people weren’t glued to their dates. Interesting.
Words. My apartment is not tiny – certainly by Manhattan standards – but that doesn’t mean it comfortably held this crowd. It didn’t. We were packed in here like happiness-seeking sardines. When the time came for the evening’s “program,” people perched wherever they could find an inch of space. I think there were at least twenty-five women on the floor. So, it was cozy. Comfortable or no, we all talked and talked. About things silly and serious. And when Gretchen began to speak, we were all captivated. She said so many interesting things about happiness, about the process of writing her book. She was witty and warm and wise.
And after saying a few words, she opened it up for questions. The questions were thoughtful and tricky and triggered a fascinating back-and-forth. Here’s a sampling:
Can happiness and ambition coexist? Gretchen referred to a professor she once had who said that these two things cannot coexist because ambition entails being in a perpetual state of dissatisfaction. Gretchen acknowledged that feeling simultaneously ambitious and happy can be a real challenge, but suggested that it is possible and involves focusing on process instead of just results. She alluded to something called “the arrival fallacy,” that belief that once we arrive somewhere or achieve something, we will be happy. Often, once we arrive at our imagined destination, we are not as happy as we thought we would be.
Would you still be happy if your book flopped? Leave it to superstar New York Times reporter Louise Story to ask this tough one. After emphasizing the importance of enjoying the processes of our lives, not just the successes of them, Gretchen was put on the spot. Would she be smiling today if here wonderful book had made no literary splash? Gretchen said that she had so much fun creating the book and doing her happiness project that she was much happier than before she started these things. But. She did admit that she would be disappointed if no one bought her book.
What do you tell your children about happiness? Maybe it is because I am knee-deep in rookie parenting, but this one grabbed me. Gretchen acknowledged that when most parents are asked what they want for their kids, the parents respond that they want their kids “to be happy.” But what does this mean? Gretchen said that she learned that this meant (1) supporting risk; and (2) Getting out of the way. Most parents think that the best thing they can do for their kids is to offer security, but Gretchen notes that children who are allowed to take risks are the most happy. (Gretchen notes how supportive her own parents were when she decided to abandon her illustrious law career to write.)
Gretchen also implored us parents to get out of our kids’ way, to let them spend their time doing what they love, rather than hovering over and trying to enrich them at all times. She said something which I cannot shake now two days later. She said that the people she knows who are happiest in their adult lives are pretty much doing what they were doing when they were ten. One friend used to watch endless television as a child and now he is a television writer. Another friend played with dollhouses much past the point of “social appropriateness” and is now an interior decorator.
This Dollhouse Hypothesis (she does not call it this) is compelling to me as a person and professional and parent. As a person, it means that we all already have the raw materials for well-being within us. That we have clues to idiosyncratic happiness in our childhoods. As a professional, it means that we are not all supposed to be following the same path. Each of us has a different proverbial dollhouse and life to play with, tinkering its contents, rearranging its cosmic furniture. As a parent, it means that it is good not to schedule every minute of my girls’ days. It means that space is good, that one of the best things I can do is let my girls become the people they will become.
Anyway, I am getting up there in words because that is what happens when I get excited and let my fingers fly. But the takeaway here is that it is good to think and to talk and to ask. It is good to dream. It is good to have scores of interesting women under one’s roof sipping wine and words from time to time.
It is good to take the time to imagine one’s childhood dollhouse, real or metaphorical. What did it look like? What went on in that little world? When the little people perched on diminutive arm chairs in the boxy little rooms, what did they talk about? When they slept in those itty-bitty beds at night, what did they dream about?
________________________
- Do you feel less self-conscious around members of your own sex?
- Do you think happiness and ambition are at odds?
- Would you be happy if you never felt true “success” in life? Is subjective enjoyment of the process of moving towards our goals “enough” or do we need some measure of objective achievement to be happy?
- Do you believe that parents should support risk-taking by their kids?
- Are you most happy doing what you were doing at age ten? What were you doing at age ten?
- Did you have a dollhouse when you were little?
- Was the fact that I wasn’t particularly fond of playing with my dollhouse a conspicuous and early sign of my lack of domesticity?
*Leave a comment here between now and 6am tomorrow (3/26/10) for a chance to win an early copy of LIFE AFTER YES. Yesterday’s winner of THE HAPPINESS PROJECT was… Jessica!*
ILI DAILY CHARMS
Writing about happiness and homes, dreams and dollhouses made me think of two posts I’ve read recently and love. And the posts are written by sisters! Speaking of sisters, Sister C was able to attend on Tuesday night and she and her college best friend stayed late chatting, sipping, and scarfing leftover cocktail sandwiches with me which contributed nicely to my Happiness Hangover. But enough about me! Check out:
You Can Never Go Home by Gale of Ten Dollar Thoughts; and
A Lost Art by Anne of Life in Pencil




Sounds like a thoroughly enriching and wonderful experience!! so much wisdome dispensed. I love the feedback on “getting out of the way” of children. I remember when I was growing up my parents allowed me to try a jillion different hobbies and activities. When I got tired of them, I quit. If something wasn’t bringing me happiness? I let it go. My parents were careful to teach perseverence in the midst of this and “practice makes perfect” and all that, but it was also freeing to be able to try whatever I wanted, instead of feeling pushed in one direction. To this day, I feel like a more enriched person because I’ve had (and continue to creat) a breadth of experiences for myself.
I love this idea of your career should be doing what you loved to do at age 10. It’s such a valid point. And I also am loving the statement to get out of the way of your children and let them take risks. It is a better offer than security. I will remember this. Thanks!
What I am most curious about — other than ALL of the other conversations that took place — is how did you advertise such an event? How does one round up 60+ people?
CONGRATS!
i agree with your dollhouse hypothesis…although I am not doing exactly what I did at 10…by 13 I really loved babysitting and knew I had to work with children….now I am a pediatric physical therapist working with kids birth-18 with special needs…which is perfect for me
i have made many decisions in my life that have changed its course and again and again, I choose happiness and a full life over a big paycheck and what others might call “success”
Being around only women is both empowering and terrifying. It is cliche that we more harshly judge one another than men judge us, so on that note being in a room full of attractive, well dressed, successful female strangers can be immensely intimidating. But on the other hand, it didn’t seem that way at all at your “happier hour.” Maybe that’s because you chose who would be there, or maybe because the topic was “happiness,” but it did seem like the “judginess” was left at door with the coats. What a wonderful evening, congratulations on living up to the salon definition of being an “inspiring hostess!”
I do think the “dollhouse hypothesis” is interesting, for myself I used to watch the Watergate hearings at 3 when they came on after Sesame Street. I loved the pointed questioning “what did the president know and when did he know it.” Of course I didn’t have a clue what they were talking about, indeed, I thought Sam Ervin lived in the neighborhood with Mr. Hooper and Bob and Susan and Maria on Sesame Street. And of course, I didn’t spend my childhood staging mock trials but I did love to perform and sing on stage and certainly in hindsight, these childhood preoccupations do seem consistent with being the happy trial lawyer that I am.
I struggle so much with the Dollhouse Hypothesis. Anne’s post (A Lost Art) alludes to this same premise and I struggled with it while reading that post as well. When I was 10 my single biggest passion was riding horses. And now I have a job in marketing.
The struggle for me is that I’m happy in my current career, but hypotheses like these cause me to question my happiness. Did I choose the wrong path? Have I fooled myself into believing I’m happy? Would I be happier as a professional equestrienne?
I do not and will not know. But I believe in asking these difficult questions, even if they sometimes take me into a frustrating cycle of doubt.
Well, Gale, marketing is sometimes like … taming wild ponies?? =>
I must have a little angel on my shoulder today. I found you through Allison Winn Scotch, and I’m so glad. My daughter is starting middle school soon and I’m struggling with protecting her from disappointment. An impossible feat! I want to say “don’t be too sad if you don’t make the cheerleading squad,” but how dare I even put that thought into her head. I will instead encourage her to go after every dream and to keep on going when she stumbles or someone places a road block in her way –just like I do everytime I send out a query and get rejected or start to write an article that isn’t flowing at first. It IS ambition — the desire to keep trying for more — that ultimately makes me happy. Otherwise, there’s not much thrill to life. I, however, never felt any ambition toward decorating my childhood dollhouse. My father made me an absolutely perfect Colonial house and I never decorated one single room. Is it any surprise that I’ve been in my house for almost 11 years and only two rooms are decorated to my liking?!
I have Life After Yes AND The Happiness Project on my list!
I don’t think that happiness and ambition cancel each other out. Or at least they don’t have to. I think it’s the most important to be happy with your life as it is right now, but part of that is striving to achieve. At least for me, if I’m not striving to achieve something it means my life is stagnant, and therefore I am less happy. So I would argue that you have to have a little ambition to be truly happy. Even if that means your are happy in your current job but you are always striving to improve.
I love the premise that as professionals we should be
“doing” what we were doing at age 10. I was (and am!) a HUGE reader as a child. Now as a lawyer, I spent hours upon hours of reading. Unfortunately, it’s not reading the types of things that I enjoy (such as LITTLE BEE by Chris Cleave – what a story). My challenge for the upcoming days, months, years, is to figure out a way that I can spend more time reading (and writing) and earn a living to pay my bills (and time to time buy a pair of fabulous shoes)!
PS Speaking of shoes, your outfit sounds pretty fabulous! Glad you had a successful happier hour.
Wow. I just got so excited reading that “dollhouse hypothesis.” I was literally having this conversation yesterday with coworkers. One was saying that she probably wouldnt let her kids watch too much tv, and i was saying that I watched a lot of TV when I was young, as did my brother, and now we both have successful careers in television, or writing about television. I spent much of my youth reading/writing, watching TV and dancing. Now I am working full-time in TV (as well as reviewing it), writing a book and blog on the side, and have taken up cardio hip-hop classes.. and I’m happier than I’ve ever been. I never really made the connection until now… Suddenly I feel like it all makes sense that I am constantly just saying I wish I was still a kid. Thanks!
Aidan – this sounds fascinating! Really, I would have loved to have been there. The idea of happy people doing the same thing they loved to do when they were ten really struck me – in the case of both me and my husband, it’s true! I spent my childhood writing stories and poems and plays; now I’m a writer and very happy and thrilled to have a career I love. My husband spent his childhood playing in the woods, outside all day long. He works in outdoor retail, and a big part of his job involves getting other people out on the water in kayaks and canoes. It’s so interesting to think of it in the context of what we loved to do as children, as opposed to what we thought we were going to ‘be when we grow up.’
Also, as far as achieving happiness and teaching our kids – I believe that for the most part, happiness is a choice we make. We could make a checklist of what we need to be happy, check every box, and still be miserable. I think it’s important to work towards our goals and dreams, but to not let our happiness be contingent upon attaining those things. Keeping happiness separate from outcome has been huge for me. I made the decision to view happiness as a choice about 6 years ago, and I can tell you with certainty I have been much happier ever since.
Thanks for the wonderful topic — you really got me energized and thinking on this. By the way, have you read Bluebird by Ariel Gore? It’s on women and happiness and positive psychology. Written like an embedded journalist sort of piece. Loved it, and highly recommend it.
-elizabeth
I am so sad that I missed it! I love what Gretchen says about our children and happiness, because it is supportive of my general philosophy to let them take risks and to let them be themselves (and by themselves).
I’ve heard this before about the fact that what you are doing when you are nine and ten is likely your life’s passion. I was reading. And writing. And that is about it. So there you go!
Your Happier Hour sounds very electrifying and a great success. Congrats!
They happy vs. ambition statement is what caught my attention. The reinforces the theory that the journey not the destination is what’s worthwhile. But once we’re happy, do we lose our ambition?
Yes, we do have to let our children take risks and learn from experience. We have to have faith in how we raise them and what we taught them. That’s the only way to let them out into the world.
As for the Dollhouse Hypothesis, I’ll have to think about that some more. At age 10, I was a competitive swimmer and I enjoyed drawing. I don’t do either of those now.
i agree wholeheartedly with allowing children to imagine and create freely. with three little boys of my own i am so pleased, and proud, that they will entertain themselves at times. the learning that goes on in these passionate play times is unbelievable. there are whole worlds out there waiting to be discovered – just let our kids play!
I am dealing with this “Dollhouse Hypothesis” right now in my life. I’m a graduate student in engineering, and never even knew what engineering WAS until college. There are things I love about it, but I find myself thinking back to the things I loved as a child, like playing “school” (I was always the teacher!), reading, and sports. Would I be happier if I were pursuing a career that incorporated some of these loves? It is an interesting topic to consider as I try to figure out my life’s path.
I agree with Gretchen that happiness and ambition can coexist, but it is a huge challenge to make that true in one’s life.
Thank you for sharing this blog with us…you always raise such interesting and universal questions!
I like the idea of your “dollhouse hypothisis”…I do think that there IS something to glean about how what made us happy when we were young has a big influence on who we become as adults. I wanted a pony more than my right arm at age 10. I got her at twelve, fast forward 15 years and I got engaged on said pony, and my husband is an organic farmer who uses horses instead of tractors. Not how I ever pictured my life turning out, but drifting through a bachelor’s and Master’s degree I never really had a clear idea of what I wanted to do with the rest of my life.
As for ambition, I don’t think wanting to do something better or more often or bigger necessarily excludes happiness with what is now. They can drive each other, as long as you don’t become so consumed with the future that you miss out on now.
Winner of early copy of LIFE AFTER YES!
I suspect the other important aspect to happiness as it pertains to your children is making sure that they are resilient. As a parent, this is tricky stuff. But so important.
Check out Denise Pope at Stanford and her Challenge Success organization.
That evening sounds so delightful! I do find that sometimes I am more comfortable in gatherings of just women, but I think, like most things, there is a time and a place for that.
I’m not at all surprised that Gretchen was witty and warm and wise. Oh, I love her writing and her wisdom.
I think ambition and happiness can co-exist if ambition is kept to a “reasonable” level. Of course, this is subjective. But everything in moderation seems to make sense. And the same about success. I don’t need to be crazy-successful, but I do hope for just a good, middle-class life. I hope for a moderate amount of success.
This Dollhouse Hypothesis is going to niggle at my brain for days to come. And I’m not sure I have many specific memories of being 10. Age 12-14 are much clearer to me. As a kid, I loved reading. I loved organizing. (I know, it’s sick. I loved emptying out a closet and reorganizing it. I loved cleaning the fridge and coming up with better schemes to put my clothes away.)
You summed it all up, Aidan – the magic, the inspiration, the take-aways. And I, too, have to put in the vote to keep it All Women. I don’t know why, but it made it safer, free-er, more comfortable….of course, your husband (& the hunky waiters!) don’t count
Thank you for making it happen, Aidan!
I love the Dollhouse Hypothesis because just yesterday I was thinking to myself, what is my passion. I asked myself that question and couldn’t come up with a specific answer like I hoped- so it’s going to give me something to reflect on. Here’s something else I thought of- do you think women have an advantage over men to pursue whatever makes them happy?
I hope Toddler and Baby realize how cool their mom is! Can’t wait to hear about more Happier Hours get togethers!!
Congrats on a successful Happier Hour! What fun! And I love what Gretchen said about getting out of “our kids’ way.” I remember my sister once lamenting that she and her husband worried that their son would never have a close relationship with his dad because he was interested in very different things – and then how relieved they were when he (the son) took up an interest that his father had. What? I thought – how about you (the parent) take an interest in what your child is interested in? Why must our children imitate us?
The Dollhouse Hypothesis – really have to keep that one in mind. But like a lot of people said here, it’s hard to know what you’re really passionate about. I, for one, do not yet know. I guess I just have to try different things and see what works for me.
Sounds like a fun evening!
(By the way, I found your blog through the link at The Happiness Project blog.)
Wow. I missed a great night! this left me with a lot to think about.. I feel like I’m always getting in my kids way. I guess it’s time to step aside and let them try to choose their own path… Let them take some risks. I’m not a huge risk taker so I fear it will be difficult but I’m starting to be convinced that it’s the right thing to do. I’m so intrigued by all of this and can’t wait to read the book.
Pingback: Tweets that mention Dollhouses & Dreams | ivy league insecurities -- Topsy.com
I’m not a risk-taker either, and I really have to be cognizant of not stepping in too often to “protect” my children from the dangers I imagine. I did, however, have a lovely dollhouse as a child … yellow, with shingles and shrubbery, all made by my dad. I can’t wait to pass it on to my daughter, along with the “do-what-you-love” message of the dollhouse hypothesis.
Art classes, music classes, tumbling classes, French classes, dance classes, creative movement classes… this wonderful city has options aplenty for my two-year-old son. Was contemplating their relative merits and came across these images of children from the developing world by photographer Steven McCurry (best known for his haunting cover shot of the Afghani refugee on an 80s National Geographic).
http://stevemccurry.wordpress.com/2009/12/09/children-at-play/#comments
They all speak to me but particularly the one of two children playing tic-tac-toe with chalk on a street. I keep it around as a reminder to myself that the happiest of childhoods isn’t about buying, nor even doing, but simply being.
Makes me want to host a Happier Hour myself! You should take it national!! And I can’t wait to read Life After Yes!
What a wonderful gift you gave to yourself and your guests! I hope you have your happier hour often!
But I am now pondering – in that major “hmmm” kind of way – about what I was happy doing at 10 years old? Reading? Talking? Certainly not dusting the living room.
Well, I guess I’ll mull over these thoughts before trying to figure out what I should be when I grow up.
ps. I’m a really fast reader – I could forward L.A.Y. to the next winner…
I want my kids to be happy and I want them to be productive functioning members of society. So I teach them to ask questions. I work with them on learning how to lose and or fail at things just as teach them how to win.
And I remind them that it is ok not to be happy all the time. Doesn’t mean that anything is wrong with you, just means that you are normal.
And I believe that you can be both happy and ambitious.
Pingback: We All Work | ivy league insecurities
Pingback: Make Every Man Want You | ivy league insecurities
Pingback: Link Love: March 2010 | When I Grow Up - Creative Career Coach